Your water heater is one of the hardest-working appliances in your home — and when it starts to fail, it rarely happens without warning. For Tyler homeowners, aging water heaters are especially common due to our hard water, temperature swings, and high seasonal demand. Ignoring the early signs can lead to cold showers, leaks, or even a flooded garage.

At Bannister Plumbing & Air, we helpEast Texas families stay ahead of unexpected breakdowns with fast, honestservice. Here are the six biggest red flags that your water heater may be nearing the end of its life.

1. Your Hot Water Isn’t Staying Hot (or Runs Out Fast)

If your showers start warm but turn lukewarm — or the hot water runs out quicker than it used to — your system islikely struggling.

Common causes in East Texas homes include:

●     Heavy sediment buildup fromTyler’s hard water

●     A failing heating element

●     A thermostat that’s no longer accurate

Sediment collects at the bottom of the tank over time, creating a barrier between the burner and the water. This forces the water heater to work harder, raising your energy bill and shortening its lifespan.

2. Rumbling or Banging Noises Coming From the Tank

Water heaters in Tyler regularly experience mineral buildup due to high calcium levels in the water supply. When sediment solidifies, you may notice:

●     Rumbling

●     Popping

●     Banging

●     Sizzling sounds

These noises mean the water heater is overheating as it bubbles water through hardened sediment. At this point,flushing may help — but loud, persistent noises usually signal that the tank is wearing out.

3. Rusty, Cloudy, or Smelly Hot Water

If only your hot water looks rusty or smells strange, the issue almost always comes from your water heater.

Signs to watch for:

●     Brown or rust-colored water (possible tank corrosion)

●     Rotten egg smell (anode rod deterioration — a big issue in areas with hard water likeTyler)

●     Metallic taste

●     Cloudy or gritty water

Rust inside the tank cannot be repaired.Once corrosion begins, the tank is in decline and replacement is usually the safest option.

4. Water Leaking or Pooling Around the Base

A small leak today can become a burst tank tomorrow.

Moisture near the system may come from:

●     A failing internal tank

●     A cracked drain valve

●     T&P valve issues

●     Condensation caused by anoverworked system

Because many Tyler homes keep water heaters in garages or closets, a leak can spread fast and go unnoticed.If you see water — even a small puddle — call a professional ASAP.

5. Your Water Heater Is 8–12 Years Old

Most traditional tank water heaters last 8–12years — and sometimes less in areas with high mineral content like EastTexas.

If your water heater is nearing that ageAND you’re noticing performance issues, planning a replacement will prevent surprise breakdowns (especially during winter or holidays when demand spikes).

Tankless systems last longer but still require annual maintenance to handle Tyler's water hardness.

6. Your Energy Bills Keep Increasing

A struggling water heater has to work harder to heat water, especially when sediment buildup or wear affects efficiency.

Signs of inefficiency include:

●     Higher electric or gas bills

●     Longer recovery time between showers

●     Temperature fluctuations throughout the day

If your energy costs are climbing without any changes in usage, your water heater could be the reason.

Repair or Replace? Here’s How to Tell

You may only need a repair if:

●     The issue is minor sediment buildup

●     The thermostat or heating element failed

●     Valves or connections need tightening

●     The unit is younger than 8 years

Replacement makes sense when:

●     The tank is leaking

●     Water is rust-colored

●     Noise is getting worse

●     The system is 10–12+ years old

●     You’ve already repaired it more than once

Investing in a new, efficient system can lower monthly costs and provide reliable hot water year-round.

 Protect Your East Texas Home Before a Breakdown Happens

A failing water heater doesn’t just inconvenience your family — it can cause serious water damage if ignored. The good news? Quick action can save you money and stress.

At Bannister Plumbing & Air,we provide:

●     Water heater flushes

●     Honest repair vs. replace evaluations

●     Fast replacements (same-day inmost cases)

●     Traditional and tankless options

●     Upfront, transparent pricing

If your water heater is showing any of these signs, don’t wait for the next cold front or holiday rush.

Schedule your water heater service with Bannister Plumbing& Air today — Tyler’s trusted plumbing experts.

‍